Doctor Ivan Lutsenko: myths and facts

Authors

  • K.K. Vasylyev Odessa National Medical University, Ukraina Author

Keywords:

Doctor Ivan Mitrofanovich Lutsenko, Ukrainian ultranationalist, civil war in Ukraine, Odessa

Abstract

Based on the data from the archives, which the author is first to introduce to the scientific community, and a critical analysis of the literature, we observe the life journey of medical doctor Ivan Mitrofanovich Lutsenko (1864–1919), whom history presents as an active figure in the epoch of the civil war in Ukraine. The author polemicizes with the historians who see Lutsenko as a hero, "a new kind of Ukrainian," and substantiates a point of view according to which I. M. Lutsenko is an ultranationalist, Russophobe, and an anti-Semite.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Vasylyev K.K. I.M. Lutsenko MD. (1863–1919)

K.K. Vasilyev. Ukrainska natsionalna ideya: istoriya

i suchasnist: Naukoviy zbirnik. (Ukrainian National

Idea: History and Present: Scientific Digest). Zhitomyr,

P. 37–38.

Vasylyev K.K. Ivan Mitrofanovich Lutsenko (1863–

. Ukrainskiy gomeopatichniy shorichnik –

Ukrainskiy gomeopatichekiy ezhegodnik. Trudy

uchastnikov VI Kongressa gomeopatov Ukrainy v Kieve

(10-12oktyabrya 2003 g.) [Ukrainian Homeopathic

Yearly. The works of the participants of the 6th

Congressional meeting of homeopaths of Ukraine in

Kiev (October 10-12 2003)]. Odessa, 2003. Vol. 6.

–45. Online access at: http://www.polykhrest.

d.ua/other/years_articles32.php

Vasylyev K.K. Ukrainskiy likar Ivan Mitrofanovich

Lutsenko (1863-1919). Aktyalny problem istirii meditsiny

Ukraini. (Ukrainian physician Ivan Mitrofanovich

Lutsenko (1863-1919). Problems of history of medicine

in Ukraine). Ternopol, 2004. P. 18–20.

Vasylyev K.K. Koli I de narodivsya Ivan Mitrofanovich

Lutsenko (1863-1919)? Meteriali XIII Kongressu

Svitovoi federatsii ekrainskih likarskih tovaristv. 30

veresnya – 2 zhivtnya 2010 roku, misto Lvov). (When

and where was Ivan Mitrofanovich Lutsenko (1863-

born? Material from the 8th Congressional meeting of World Federation of Ukrainian Association of Physicians. September 30 – October 3 2010 in Lviv).

viv, Kiev, Chicago, 2010. P. 91.

Vasylyev K.K. K istorii gomeopatii v Odesse do 1917

goda. Ukrainskiy gomeopatichniy shorichnik –

Ukrainskiy gomeopaticheskiy ezhegodnik. (On the

history of homeopathy in Odessa prior to 1917).

Ukrainian Homeopathic Yearly. Odessa, 2001. Vol.

P. 44–47. Online access at: http://www.polykhrest.

d.ua/other/years_articles115.php

Vasylyev K.K. Zur Geschichte der Homöopathie im

Russischen Reich bis 1917: Homöopathie in Odessa.

Von Samuel Gottlieb Gmelins Reise durch Russland

bis zum Niedergang der Apothekerfamilie Poehl:

Vorträge des Symposiums am Institut für Medizin –

und Wissenschaftsgeschichte Lübeck und der

Ostseeakademie Travemünde vom 30. September bis 1.

Oktober 2000. R. Pfrepper, I. Küstner, D. v. Engelhardt

(Hgg.). Aachen, 2001. S. 241–250.

Zlenko G.D. Kto vy, doctor Lutsenko? Beglyi nabrosok

portreta. (Who are you, Doctor Lutsenko? A quick

sketch. Yug. 1996, 31. VIII, № 130 (14168). P. 5.

Zlenko G.D. Likar i borets za ukrainsku derzhavnist: [I.

Lutsenko]. VI congress Svitovoi federatsii ukrainskih likarskih

tovarist, 9-14 veres. 1996 r. (A physician and a fighter for the

Ukrainian statehood). Tez.dop. Odessa, 1996. P. 8.

Zlenko G.D. Vin zhiv vifrozhennyam kozatstva. (He

lived by the rebirth of the Cossacks). [I. Lutsenko].

Chyornomors’ki novyny. 1997, 23. IV, № 32 (19530). P. 3.

Zlenko G.D. Povernennya Ivana Lutsenka. (The return

of Ivan Lutsenko). Vechernyaya Odessa. 2001. Vol. 17,

№ 26. P. 4.

Zlenko G.D., Moshich O.P. Vidatni osobistosti ukrainskoi

istorii (Ivan Mitrofanovich Lutsenko – dotkor meditsini,

gomeopath, derzhavniy diyach). [The outstanding figure

of Ukrainian history (Ivan Mitrofanovich Lutsenko –

the doctor of medicine, homeopath, state worker)].

Ukrainian Homeopathic Yearly. Works of the VI

Congress. Odessa, 2003. P. 45–48.

Ivaniv A.P. Ivan Mitrofanovich Lutsenko v istorii

otechestvennoi gomeopatii. (Ivan Mitrofanovich

Lutsenko in the history of the Russian homeopathy).

Ukrainian Homeopatic Yearly. The worksof

VI Congress. Odessa, 2003. P. 48−53.

Vintskovskiy T.S. Lutsenko pri vilno-kozatsku

organizatsiyu. Ukrainske kozatstvo u vitchiznyaniy

ta zagalnoevropeiskiy istorii. Mizhnarodna naukova

konferentsiya. Tezi dopovidei. (Lutsenko in free

Cossack organizations. Ukrainian Cossacks in

Patriotic and and general European history). Odessa,

P. 61−62.

Zlenko G.D. Povernennya Ivana Lutsenka. Litsari

dosvitnih vogniv. 33 portrechi diyachiv odeskoi

“Prosviti” 1905-1909 rokiv. (The return of Ivan

Lutsenko. Litsari dosvitnih vogniv. 33 portraits of the

figures of Odessa “Education” during 1905–1909).

Odessa, 2005. P. 29−42.

Vintskovskiy T.S., Muzichko O.E. Ivan Lutsenko

v ukrainskomu natsionalnomu rusi kintsiya XIX–

pochatkuXXst. tskovskiy, O.E. Muzichko (Ivan

Lutsenko and the national movement between

the end of the XIX and the beginning of the XX

centuries). Ukrainian historical journal. 2009. №4.

–106.

Vintskovskiy T.S., Muzichko O.E. Ivan Lutsenko:

viyskoviy likar – pretendent na getmana Ukraini.

Chernomorska hvilya Ukrainskoi revolyutsii: providniki

natsionalnogo ruhu v Odesi u 1917-1920 rr. (Ivan

Lutsenko: a military physician – contender for the

Cossack chieftain position of Ukraine. The Black Sea

wave revolution in Ukraine: the conductors of the

national movement in Odessa during 1917–1920).

Odessa, 2011. P. 105–131.

Verstyk V., Ostashko T. Mriyav pro nezalezhist.

[I.М. Lutsenko]. Historical calendar of the 1999. K.,

P. 101–102.

Verstyuk V.F., Ostashko T.S. Lutsenko I.M. Ostashko

Diyachi Ukrainskoi Tsentralnoi Radi. Biografichniy

dovidnik. (A member of the Ukrainian Central Council.

Biographical directory). Kiev, 1998. P. 119.

Sidorenko H. I.M. Lutsenko. Ukrainska zhurnalistika

v imenah. Materiali do entsiklopedichnogo slovnika.

(The names in Ukrainian journalism. Materials for the

encyclopedic dictionary). Lvov, 2002. P. 191–192.

Lutsenko I.M. Entsiklopediya istorii Ukrainy.

(Encyclopedia of Ukrainian history). Kiev, 2009. Vol. 6.

–307. Not signed.

Muzichko O.E. I.M. Lutsenko. Odeski istoriki,

Entsiklopedichne vidannya. (Historians of Odessa.

Encyclopedias). Odessa, 2009. Vol, 1: the beginning of

the XIX–the middle the XX centuries. P. 221–223.

Tinchenko Y. Lutsenko I.M. Ofitserskiy korpus armii

Ukrainskoi Narodnoi Respubliki (1917–1921). [The

officership of the army of the People’s Republic of

Ukraine (1917-1921)]. K., 2007. Book. 1. P. 256.

Meditsina v Ukraini. Bibliografichnyi slovnik. Druga

polovina XIX–pochatok XX stoletiya. (Medicine in

Ukraine. Bobliographical dictionary. The second half of

the XIX–beginning of the XX century). Literi L–S. K.,

Ed. 2. P. 41–42.

Vintskovskiy T., Muzichko O. Ivan Mitofanovich

Lutsenko (1863-1919): ukrainskiy natsietvorec. (Ivan

Mitrofanovich Lutsenki (1863-1919): father of the

nation). Kiev, 2013. P. 351.

Strizhevskiy A.I. Svitloi pamyati Ivana Mitrofanovicha

Lutsenko. (In good memory of Ivan Mitrofanovich

Lutsenko). [Republication of the memoirs of 1922].

(Compiler, author of the foreword, introductory articles and

comments Oleksandr Muzichko). Odessa, 2011. P. 101.

Lipa I. Svitilnik neugasimyi. Pamyati Ivana Lipi.

(Undying lantern. In memory of Ivan Lipa). Odessa;

Lvov: edited by Narodniy Styag, 1924. P. 35.

Lutsenko I.M. Rosiiskiy meditskinskiy spisok na 1903

god. (Russian medical list of 1903). SPb., 1903. P. 202.

Lutsenko Ivan. Entsiklopedia Ukrainoznavstva.

(Encyclopedia of Ukrainian Studies). Lvov, 1994. Vol. 4.

Lutsenko I. Encyclopedia of Urkaine. Toronto; Buffalo;

London, 1993. Vol. 3. P. 221.

urriculim vitae. Lutsenko I.M. K ucheniyu o kurinoi

slepote. (Istoriya odnoi epidemii kurinoi slepoty i ocherk

ucheniya ob etoi bolezni). (The story of one epidemic

of hemeralopia and notes on the study of this disease)

SPb., 1893. P. 83–84.

Rossiyskiy godudarstvennyi voenno-istoricheskiy

arhiv. (Russian state military-historical archive).

Op. 65. D. 185. 13 l. (A case file on the student I.M. Lutsenko).

Gosudarstvennyi arhiv odesskoi oblasti. (State archive

of the Odessa region). F. 64. Op. 1. D. 894. 6 l. (About

the listener of I.M. Lutsenko).

Lutsenko I.M. Rossiyskiy meditsinskiy spisok na 1897

god. (Russian medical list of 1897). SPb., 1897. P. 170.

Lutsenko I.M. Rossiyskiy meditsinskiy spisok na 1898

god. (Russian medical list of 1898). SPb., 1898. P. 173.

Lutsenko I.M. K voprosu o znachenii teorii

veroyatnostei dlya meditsiny. (On the importance of

the probability theory for medicine). Physician. 1888.

№50. P. 1000–002.

Lutsenko I.M. Deistvie saharina na serdtse. (The action

of saccharin on the heart). Medicine. 1891. № 2. P. 24.

Lutsenko I.M. K ucheniyu o kurinoi slepote. (On the

study of hemerolapia). Military-historical journal. 1893.

Vol. 178, № 9, nonofficial part. P. 16–90.

Lipa Y.I. Odeska “Sich”. (Odessa January). Za

derzhavnist. Meteriali do istorii viyska Ukrainskogo.

(For the country. Materials on the history of Ukrainian

troops). Kalish, 1935. Collection 5. P. 207–208.

Lipa Y.I. Dva roki. Simnadsyatyi i visimnadsyatyi. (Two

years. Seventeen and Eighteen). Almanac “New time”.

(“Calendar for everyone”). For the year 1938. Lvov,

P. 9–17.

Lipa Y.I. Nash optimism i yogo pidstavi. (Our optimism

and its foundation). Black See Compilation. Odessa,

Book. 4. P. 5–9.

Odessa. Kratkiy spravochnik. (Brief reference book).

Odessa, 1948. P. 36–37.

Mustafin V.A. Samostoyatelnaya Ukraina. Pravlenie

Rady. 1917 god v sudbah Rossii i mira. Oktyabrskaya

revolyutsiya. Ot novyh istochnikov k novomu

osmysleniyu. (Independent Ukraine. Governance of

Rada. Year 1917 in the lives of Russia and the world.

The October Revolution. From new sources to new

understanding). M., 1998. P. 338–401.

Muzichko O. Obraz revolyutsinnoi Odesi ta postati

I.M. Lutsenka v memuarah A.I. Strizhevskogo. (The

image and of the revolutionary Odessa and the figure

of I.M. Lutsenko in memoirs of A.I. Strizhevskogo).

Strizhevskiy A.I. In good memory of Ivan Mitrofanovich

Lutsenko. [Republication of memoirs of 1922].

(Compiler, author of the foreword, introductory articles

and comments Oleksandr Muzichko). Odessa, 2011.

–67.

Skoropadskiy P. Vospominaniya. Konets 1917 – dekabr

(Memoirs. The end of 1917 – the end of 1918) /

Skoropadskiy. K.; Philadelphia, 1995. P. 493.

Krah germanskoi sistemy okkupatsii na Ukraine. (Po

dokumentam okkupantov). [The crash of the German

occupational system in Ukraine. (according to the

documents of the occupants)]. B.m., 1936. P. 207.

Downloads

Published

2014-02-28

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite