Boorse and Galen: an overlooked connection
Keywords:
history of medicine, philosophy of medicine, naturalistic theory, Galen, Christopher Boorse, teleology, functionalismAbstract
This article examines the important issue of how the philosophy and history of medicine influence each other and the need to take account of this when considering fundamental concepts of ontological significance to medical science.
he author analyses one of the most significant modern theories in the philosophy of medicine — the naturalistic theory put forward by Boorse. The latter suggests regarding how fully the function of a particular body part, organ,or the organism as a whole, is performed as a criterion by which the organism’s condition can be assessed: whether it is healthy or sick depends on how fully particular functions are performed. Boorse’s theory refers to the statistically typical level of a particular function for a biological species overall, and effectively suggests that functions can be quan-titatively assessed. The functionalist approach has always been extremely important to the development of medical theory and practice. The author notes that Boorse’s theory has a strong ontological connection to the teleological tradition in the history of medicine, first clearly expressed by Galen. The link between Boorse’s ideas and Galen’s views is substantial, but, apparently, no one, not even Boorse himself, has previously recognised it. The author asks whether it is possible to put forward a convincing modern philosophical theory of an applied science such as medicine while ignoring its history.
Downloads
References
Aas S, Wasserman D (2016) Disability, Disease, and
Health Sufficiency. What is Enough?: Sufficiency, Justice, and Health. Eds. C. Fourie, A. Rid.
Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/acprof:
oso/9780199385263.003.0010
Amundson R (2000) Against Normal Function. Stud Hist
Phil Biol & Biomed Sci 31(1): 33–53. DOI: 10.1016/
s1369-8486(99)00033-3
Amundson R (2001) Adaptation, Development, and the
Quest for Common Ground. Adaptation and Optimality. Eds. S.H. Orzack, E. Sober. New York: Cambridge University Press. P. 303‒334.
Amundson R (2005) Disability, ideology, and quality of
life: a bias in biomedical ethics. Quality of life and
human difference. Eds. D. Wasserman, J. Bickenbach,
R. Wachbroit. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press. P. 101‒124.
Amundson R (2009) Evolutionary developmental biology. Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Taylor and
Francis. DOI: 10.4324/9780415249126-Q123-1
Amundson R (2010) Quality of Life, Disability, and
Hedonic Psychology. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 40(4): 374‒392. DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-
2010.00437.x
Amundson R (2012) Homology and Homoplasy: A Philosophical Perspective. Encyclopedia of life sciences.
Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Published online: 15 October 2012. DOI: 10.1002/9780470015902.
a0003445.pub2
Amundson R (2015) Preface. Conceptual Change in Biology: Scientific and Philosophical Perspectives on
Evolution and Development. Ed. A.C. Love. Berlin:
Springer. P. V‒X.
Amundson R, Tresky S (2007) On a Bioethical Challenge to
Disability Rights. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy
(6): 541—561. DOI: 10.1080/03605310701680924
Amundson R, Tresky S (2008) Bioethics and Disability
Rights: Conflicting Values and Perspectives. Bioethical
Inquiry 5(2—3): 111–123. DOI: 10.1007/s11673-008-
-3
Balalykin DA (2015) Meditsina Galena: traditsiya Gippokrata i ratsionalnost antichnoy naturfilosofii [Galen’s medicine: the Hippocratic tradition and the
rationality of ancient natural philosophy]. Galen.
Sochineniya [Works]. Vol. 2. Ed., comp., introd., and
annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow: Prakticheskaya
meditsina. P. 5‒106. (In Russ.)
Balalykin DA, Shcheglov AP, Shok NP (2014) Galen:
vrach i filosof [Galen: a doctor and philosopher]. Moscow: Vest. 416 p. (In Russ.)
Bolton D (2008) What is Mental Disorder? An essay in
philosophy, science, and values. Oxford University
Press.
Boorse C (1977) Health as a Theoretical Concept. Philosophy of Science 44 (4): 542‒573. DOI: 10.1086/288768
Boorse C (1997) A rebuttal on health. What Is Disease?
Eds. J.M. Humber, R.F. Almeder. Totowa, NJ: Humana
Press. P. 1‒134.
Boorse C (2002) A rebuttal on functions. Functions: New
Essays in the Philosophy of Psychology and Biology.
Eds. A. Ariew, R. Cummins, M. Perlman. Oxford: Oxford University Press. P. 63‒112.
Boorse C (2011) Concepts of health and disease. Philosophy of Medicine. Ed.F. Gifford. North Holland.
P. 13‒64.
Boorse C (2014) A second rebuttal on health. J Med
Philos 39(6): 683‒724. DOI: 10.1093/jmp/jhu035
Claudii Galeni Opera Omnia (1821–1833) Ed.
K.G. Kühn. Leipzig.
Cooper R (2002) Disease. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 33 (2):
‒282. DOI: 10.1016/S0039-3681(02)00018-3
Galen K (1971) O naznachenii chastey chelovecheskogo
tela [The Function of the Parts of the Body]. Transl.
by S.P. Kondratev, ed. by V.N. Ternovskiy. Moscow:
Meditsina. (In Russ.)
Galen (2005) De placitis Hippocratis et Platonis. Galen.
On the doctrines of Hippocrates and Plato. Ed., transl.,
comm. Ph. De Lacy. Berlin: Akademie-Verlag.
Galen (2014a) Sposob raspoznavaniya i lecheniya strastey
lyuboy, v tom chisle i svoey sobstvennoy, dushi [The
Diagnosis and Treatment of the Aff ections and Errors
Peculiar to Each Person’s Soul]. Galen. Sochineniya
[Works]. Vol. 1. Ed., comp., introd., and annot. bу
D.A. Balalykin. Moscow: Vest. P. 214‒248. (In Russ.)
Galen (2014b) O raspoznavanii i lechenii zabluzhdeniy
vsyakoy dushi [The Diagnosis and Cure of the Soul’s
Passions]. Galen. Sochineniya [Works]. Vol. 1. Ed.,
comp., introd., and annot. bу D.A. Balalykin Moscow:
Vest. P. 281‒302. (In Russ.)
Galen (2014c) O zavisimosti svoystv dushi ot temperamentov tela [The Capacities of the Soul Depend on the
Mixtures of the Body]. Galen. Sochineniya [Works].
Vol. 1. Ed., comp., introd., and annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow: Vest. P. 339‒376. (In Russ.)
Galen (2015a) Iskusstvo meditsiny [The Art of Medicine]. Galen. Sochineniya [Works]. Vol. 2. Ed., comp.,
introd., and annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow: Prakticheskaya meditsina. P. 172‒230. (In Russ.)
Galen (2015b) K Patrofilu, o sostave meditsinskogo
iskusstva [On the Constitution of the Art of Medicine]. Galen. Sochineniya [Works]. Vol. 2. Ed., comp.,
introd., and annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow: Prakticheskaya meditsina. P. 292‒334. (In Russ.)
Galen (2015c) O raznovidnostyakh bolezney [Types of
Diseases]. Galen. Sochineniya [Works]. Vol. 2. Ed.,
comp., introd., and annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow:
Prakticheskaya meditsina. P. 578‒604. (In Russ.)
Galen (2015d) O raznovidnostyakh simptomov [Distinctions in Symptoms]. Galen. Sochineniya [Works].
Vol. 2. Ed., comp., introd., and annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow: Prakticheskaya meditsina. P. 700‒727.
(In Russ.)
Galen (2015e) Fragmenty kommentariya k “Timeyu”
Platona [Commentary on Plato’s “Timaeus”]. Galen.
Sochineniya [Works]. Vol. 2. Ed., comp., introd., and
annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow: Prakticheskaya
meditsina. P. 759‒781. (In Russ.)
Galen (2016) Ob ucheniyakh Gippokrata i Platona
[On the doctrines of Hippocrates and Plato]. Books
–5. Galen. Sochineniya [Works]. Vol. 3. Ed., comp.,
introd., and annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow: Prakticheskaya meditsina. 560 p. (In Russ.)
Galen (2017) Ob ucheniyakh Gippokrata i Platona
[On the doctrines of Hippocrates and Plato]. Books
–9. Galen. Sochineniya [Works]. Vol. 4. Ed., comp.,
introd., and annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow: Prakticheskaya meditsina. 494 p. (In Russ.)
Galen (2018) O estestvennykh funktsiyakh [Natural
Faculties]. Galen. Sochineniya [Works]. Vol. 5. Ed.,
comp., introd., and annot. bу D.A. Balalykin. Moscow:
Prakticheskaya meditsina. P. 183‒305. (In Russ.)
Guerrero JD (2010) On a naturalist theory of health:
a critique. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 41 (3): 272‒278. DOI:
1016/j.shpsc.2009.12.008
Kuhn TS (2014) After “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions”. Moscow: AST. 443 с. (In Russ.)
Kukla R (2014) Medicalization, “Normal Function,” and
the Definition of Health. The Routledge Companion to Bioethics. Eds. J.D. Arras, E. Fenton, R. Kukla.
Abingdon: Routledge. Routledge Handbooks Online.
DOI: 10.4324/9780203804971.ch39
Nordenfelt L (1987) On the Nature of Health: An ActionTheoretic Approach. Dordrecht, Boston: D. Reidel.
Silvers A (1998) A Fatal Attraction to Normalizing: Treating Disabilities as Deviation from “Species-Typical”
Functioning. Enhancing Human Traits: Ethical and
Social Implications. Ed.E. Parens. Washington, DC:
Georgetown University Press. P. 95—123.
Schroeder SA (2013) Rethinking health: healthy or
healthier than? British Journal for the Philosophy of
Science 64(1): 131‒159. DOI: 10.1093/bjps/axs006
Schwartz PH (2007) Defining dysfunction: natural selection, design, and drawing a line. Philosophy of Science
(3): 364‒385. https://doi.org/10.1086/521970
Temkin O (1973a) Health and Disease. Dictionary of
the History of Ideas. Vol. 2. New York: Scribner’s.
P. 395‒407.
Temkin O (1973b) Galenism: Rise and Decline of a Medical Philosophy. Ithaca, London: Cornell University
Press.
Vácha J (1978) Biology and the Problem of Normality.
Scientia 113: 823–846.
Venkatapuram S (2011) Health Justice: An argument
from the capabilities approach. Cambridge: Polity
Press.
Vernadsky VI (1989) Biosphere and noosphere. Moscow:
Nauka. (In Russ.)
Vernadsky VI (1991) Scientific thought as a planetary
phenomenon. Moscow: Nauka. (In Russ.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
You are free to:
- Share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format for any purpose, even commercially.
- Adapt — remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially.
- The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as long as you follow the license terms.
Under the following terms:
- Attribution — You must give appropriate credit , provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made . You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use.
- No additional restrictions — You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that legally restrict others from doing anything the license permits.
Notices:
You do not have to comply with the license for elements of the material in the public domain or where your use is permitted by an applicable exception or limitation .
No warranties are given. The license may not give you all of the permissions necessary for your intended use. For example, other rights such as publicity, privacy, or moral rights may limit how you use the material.
