Manchurian Plague of 1910–1911 in newspaper cartoons part 2)1

Authors

  • Pavel E. Ratmanov FSBEI HE FESMU MOH Russia Muravieva-Amurskogo St., 35, Khabarovsk 680000, Russia, Author

Keywords:

plague, epidemic, China, the social history of medicine, D.K. Zabolotny, periodicals, Manchuria

Abstract

The article presents an analysis and interpretation of the satirical illustrations published in the Harbin newspaper Novaya Zhizn on the events connected with the pneumonic plague epidemic in Harbin (1910–1911). Bureaucracy and the ineffectiveness of a number of medical measures were subject to criticism. The satire in Novaya Zhizn was mainly aimed at finding those guilty for the epidemic. In the winter of 1910–1911, the board of the Chinese Eastern Railway sent a group of epidemiologists to Harbin. The group was headed by Professor D.K. Zabolotny, who became one of the initiators of vaccinations against the plague, and the elimination of rodents, which were the infection’s presumed vectors. The relationship between Harbin doctors and Zabolotny was tense from the very beginning, growing into an open confrontation in April 1911. At the end of May 1911,a group of doctors announced that Zabolotny did not allow Harbin doctors to attend the Mukden conference. Officially, the conflict was not resolved, as Zabolotny urgently left Harbin for Transbaikal, where his expedition for the first time isolated the causative agent of the plague from tarbagans. Harbin’s various social groups at that time had different views on the events related to the plague epidemic. In this article only one view is studied – that of the Russian-speaking community in Harbin,reflected in a series of cartoons from the Novaya Zhizn newspaper. The illustrations that have been analyzed show that the events related to the pulmonary plague epidemic in Harbin and the serious differences that arose at that time in the medical environment did not remain unnoticed by the Harbin public and confirm the public interest in health care and its medical representatives.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bogutskiy V.M. Epidemiya chumy v Kharbine i

ego okrestnostyakh v polose otchuzhdeniya KVZhD.

–1911 gg. Meditsinskiy otchet o deyatel’nosti

protivochumnogo byuro. Chast’ 1 [The plague in Harbin

and the surrounding area in the zone of CER. 1910–1911.

Medical report on the activities anti-plague Bureau. Part 1].

Harbin, 1911. (in Russian)

Kastorskiy E.S. Epidemiya legochnoy chumy na Dal’nem

Vostoke 1910–1911 gg. i mery bor’by s neyu [The

epidemic of pneumonic plague in the Far East in 1910–

and measures to combat it]. Irkutsk: Tipografiya

M.P. Okuneva, 1911. (in Russian)

Khmara-Borshchevskiy E.P. Chumnye epidemii

na Dal’nem Vostoke i protivochumnye meropriyatiya

Upravleniya Kitayskoy Vostochnoy zheleznoy dorogi

[Plague Epidemics in the Far East and Anti-Plague

Measures taken by the CER Administration]. Harbin:

Novaya zhizn, 1912. (in Russian)

Tishenko P.S. Kitayskaya Vostochnaya zheleznaya

doroga. 1903–1913 gg. [Chinese Eastern Railway. 1903–

. Harbin, 1914. (in Russian)

Gubert V.I. Chuma i mery bor’by s neyu v Odesse [Plague

and measures to combat it in Odessa]. Saint Petersburg,

P. 17–92. (in Russian)

Chuma v Odesse v 1910 g.: epidemiologiya, patologiya,

klinika, bakteriologiya i meropriyatiya [The plague

in Odessa in 1910: Epidemiology, pathology, clinical

bacteriology and activities]. Eds. L.N. Malinovskiy,

D.K. Zabolotnyy, P.N. Bulatov. Komissiya o merakh

preduprezhdeniya i bor’by s chumnoy zarazoy, 1912.

(in Russian)

Martinevskiy I.L., Mollyaret H. Epidemiya chumy v

Man’chzhurii v 1910–1911 gg. (geroicheskiy podvig

russkikh i frantsuzskikh vrachey v bor’be s ney) [The

Plague Epidemic in Manchuria, 1910–1911 (Heroism of

Russian and French Physicians in the Fight against it)].

Moscow, 1971. (in Russian)

Summers W.C. The Great Manchurian Plague of

–1911: The Geopolitics of an Epidemic Disease.

New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 2012.

DOI:10.12987/yale/9780300183191.001.0001

Iij ima W. The establishment of Japanese Colonial

Medicine: Infectious and Parasitic Disease Studies in

Taiwan, Manchuria, and Korea under the Japanese Rule

before WWII. Aoyama Shigaku. 2010; 77–106.

Gamsa M. The Epidemic of Pneumonic Plague in

Manchuria 1910–1911. Past and Present. 2006; 190:

–183. DOI:10.1093/pastj/gtj001

Budberg R. Bilder aus der Zeit der Lungenpest-Epidemien

in der Mandschurei, 1910/11 und 1921. Hamburg: Verlag

von Conrad Behre, 1923.

Gamsa M. China as Seen and Imagined by Roger Baron

Budberg, a Baltic Physician in Manchuria. Eastwards:

Western Views on East Asian Culture. Bern: Peter Lang,

P. 23–35.

Chevé D., Signoli M. Corps dans la tourmente

épidémique; images de peste en Mandchourie. Corps.

; 75–92. DOI:10.3917/corp.002.0075

Lynteris C. The Epidemiologist as Culture Hero:

Visualizing Humanity in the Age of ‘the Next

Pandemic’. Vis Anthropol. 2016; 29: 36–53.

DOI: 10.1080/08949468.2016.1108823

Lynteris C., Prince R.J. Anthropology and Medical

Photography: Ethnographic, Critical and Comparative

Perspectives. Vis Anthropol. 2016; 29: 101–117.

DOI: 10.1080/08949468.2016.1131104

Sherstneva E.V., Poddubnyy M.V. Meditsinskiy plakat

kak sredstvo sanitarnogo prosveshcheniya v 20-e gody

[Medical poster as a means of health education in the

s.]. Problemy sotsial’noy gigieny zdravookhraneniya

i istorii meditsiny [Problems of Social Hugiene, Public

Health and History of Medicine]. 2001; 3: 61–64.

(in Russian)

Bakich O.M. Émigré Identity: The Case of Harbin.

South Atlantic Quarterly. 2000; 99: 51–73.

DOI: 10.1215/00382876-99-1-51

Downloads

Published

2017-06-30

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

E. Ratmanov, P. (2017). Manchurian Plague of 1910–1911 in newspaper cartoons part 2)1. History of Medicine, 4(3). https://historymedjournal.com/HOM/index.php/medicine/article/view/174